Constitutional Court Upholds Endrit Shabani’s Election as Ombudsman

0

The Constitutional Court has published the reasoning behind its decision rejecting a request by 44 opposition lawmakers to overturn the election of Endrit Shabani as head of the Ombudsman institution. The ruling leaves in force the act adopted by parliament on December 11, 2025, when Shabani received 85 votes in favor.

Constitutional Court Upholds Endrit Shabani’s Election as Ombudsman

Why the opposition’s request was rejected

In decision No. 85, dated September 29, 2026, the Constitutional Court found that the procedure followed for Shabani’s election did not violate the Constitution. This means that, in the court’s reading, no such violations were found as would have been sufficient to overturn parliament’s decision.

The lawsuit was filed on January 12, 2026 by 44 lawmakers, who requested verification of the candidate’s eligibility and incompatibility, as well as the annulment of the parliamentary decision. With this ruling, their claims were not accepted.

Supporting signatures and withdrawal after the deadline

One of the central points of the dispute concerned the supporting signatures of Democratic Party lawmakers. According to the Constitutional Court’s reasoning, Endrit Shabani had secured 35 signatures within the prescribed deadline, while the request to withdraw support was made on December 5, 2025, after the deadline had expired.

The court held that a supporting signature produces legal effect at the moment it is filed and cannot later be undone in order to invalidate a candidate’s qualification. It also distinguished between the signature used to enter the race and the vote in the plenary session, where lawmakers remain free to vote in favor, against, or abstain.

Claims of political incompatibility

The opposition also raised the issue of Shabani’s previous political engagement, arguing that he had been chairman of Nisma Thurje and a member of the Tirana Municipal Council, while the formal procedures for leaving those functions, according to them, had not been fully completed at the time of his candidacy.

But the Constitutional Court interpreted that the determining moment for verifying incompatibility is not the candidacy, but the start of the exercise of office. Shabani was elected on December 11, 2025 and took the oath on December 18. According to the court, it was not proven that at the moment he assumed office he was exercising functions incompatible with the post.

Professional criteria in parliament’s hands

Another objection concerned the candidate’s professional criteria, particularly his knowledge and activity in the field of human rights and law. Here, the Constitutional Court took a restrained approach to its role, stressing that the assessment of professional merit is a competence of parliament.

According to the ruling, constitutional review does not replace parliament’s political and procedural judgment, but verifies only whether it has been exercised within constitutional limits and without arbitrariness. In this case, the court said arbitrariness in the review of the candidacy by the Laws Committee was not proven.

With the publication of the reasoning, it has become clearer that the Constitutional Court gave weight to procedural deadlines, the distinction between formal support and the political vote, as well as parliament’s dominant role in filtering candidacies for this post.

As a result, Endrit Shabani’s election as Ombudsman remains in force.

Artikulli i mëparshëmBig Brother VIP Albania rikthehet në dhjetor, njoftimi u bë me një spot në Instagram
Artikulli i radhësRama mbledh ministrat dhe drejtuesit e PS në Kryeministri, në fokus zgjedhjet vendore 2027